开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

mimì🍬 · 2023年08月27日

Mutual fund VS ETF 哪个流动性更好?

NO.PZ2023010903000021

问题如下:

At the next board meeting, Cullen begins by introducing passive investing to Sapphire’s board. He states that open-end mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are appropriate approaches. Both alternatives are readily available, offer a broad spectrum of investment choices, and are easy to buy and sell. He makes the following comments comparing the two alternatives.

l 1 Both mutual funds and ETFs can be purchased on margin.

l 2 Investors can take short positions in ETFs but not in mutual funds.

l 3 Both mutual funds and ETFs have the same degree of liquidity.

In comparing mutual funds and ETFs, Cullen is most accurate in:

选项:

A.

Comment 1

B.

Comment 2

C.

Comment 3

解释:

Only ETF investors can take short positions.

A is incorrect. Only ETF investors can purchase shares on margin.

C is incorrect. Mutual funds and ETFs do not have the same degree of liquidity. Although ETFs allow for inter-day trading they could experience periods of market illiquidity. Mutual fund units are redeemed directly from the mutual fund.

etf 会有risk of market illiquid。 但如果跟mutual fund比还是etf流动性更好吧?因为etf有公开市场。为什么李老师解析里说的感觉像是etf流动性更差一样?

1 个答案

笛子_品职助教 · 2023年08月28日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


Mutual Fund流动性更好,这在原版书上有明确的结论。

因为在美国市场,二级市场交易的ETF,流动性很差,成交量很小,大额资金想在二级市场进出,很难做到。

而mutual fund,是申购,可以大额资金申购和赎回。


同学可能是把国内的情形带入了,国内有些ETF流动性确实不错。但是我们考CFA,还是要遵照美国的实证国情以及CFA给出的结论。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!

  • 1

    回答
  • 2

    关注
  • 265

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023010903000021问题如下 the next boarmeeting, Cullen begins introcing passive investing to Sapphire’s boar He states thopen-enmutufun anexchange-trafun (ETFs) are appropriate approaches. Both alternatives are realy available, offer a brospectrum of investment choices, anare easy to buy ansell. He makes the following comments comparing the two alternatives.l 1 Both mutufun anETFs cpurchaseon margin.l 2 Investors ctake short positions in ETFs but not in mutufun.l 3 Both mutufun anETFs have the same gree of liquity.In comparing mutufun anETFs, Cullen is most accurate in: A.Comment 1B.Comment 2C.Comment 3 Only ETF investors ctake short positions.A is incorrect. Only ETF investors cpurchase shares on margin.C is incorrect. Mutufun anETFs not have the same gree of liquity. Although ETFs allow for inter-y trang they coulexperienperio of market illiquity. Mutufununits are reemerectly from the mutufun 如题,关于ETF可以做空和保证金交易这两点印象很模糊,能否讲解一下?为什么mutufun不能做空和保证金交易呢?另外这个purchase in margin指的是ETF的一级市场还是二级市场?

2024-03-06 20:31 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023010903000021 问题如下 the next boarmeeting, Cullen begins introcing passive investing to Sapphire’s boar He states thopen-enmutufun anexchange-trafun (ETFs) are appropriate approaches. Both alternatives are realy available, offer a brospectrum of investment choices, anare easy to buy ansell. He makes the following comments comparing the two alternatives.l 1 Both mutufun anETFs cpurchaseon margin.l 2 Investors ctake short positions in ETFs but not in mutufun.l 3 Both mutufun anETFs have the same gree of liquity.In comparing mutufun anETFs, Cullen is most accurate in: A.Comment 1 B.Comment 2 C.Comment 3 Only ETF investors ctake short positions.A is incorrect. Only ETF investors cpurchase shares on margin.C is incorrect. Mutufun anETFs not have the same gree of liquity. Although ETFs allow for inter-y trang they coulexperienperio of market illiquity. Mutufununits are reemerectly from the mutufun 通俗的说,就是借钱去买?那我自己借了钱,然后去买基金这不算吗?就有没有什么特别的定义呀?

2023-07-13 22:24 1 · 回答